I've calculated mileage with both an 08 sedan w/automatic and a 08 hatchback manual(my car). The sedan was a loaner car.
On the sedan I got no more than 30 mpg. With my hatchback, I regularly get 37mpg. On good days I've managed 40mpg, and when I drive it hard I've seen no less than 35mpg.
You won't catch me driving an automatic on a daily basis.