•  
    Results 1 to 10 of 10

    Thread: Is this a bad coil?

    1. #1
      Should I keep it?
      Join Date
      Mar 2015
      Location
      Los Angeles
      Posts
      43
      Thanks
      5
      Thanked 6 Times in 3 Posts

      Is this a bad coil?

      Checking my coil I found some sparks coming from one of the connectors. Wonder if I should replace it, I've been having some P0300 codes.


      In this pictures the sparks are traveling all around outside the connector.
      Name:  IMG_20150328_104929.jpg
Views: 3663
Size:  65.0 KB


      In this other connector there is almost no spark.
      Name:  IMG_20150328_104947.jpg
Views: 1914
Size:  63.4 KB



    2. #2
      Almost time to do my timing belt xintersecty's Avatar
      Join Date
      Sep 2010
      Location
      West Union, SC
      Posts
      1,687
      Thanks
      86
      Thanked 181 Times in 156 Posts
      Actually sparks good, no sparks not good. The whole point is bring the voltage to 30KV or something like that. If it sparks while you have a wire on it that's bad. So the spark is indicating the coil is working. BTW nice picture of the sparks.
      Please do not power off, firmware update pending.....

    3. #3
      I'll keep it and add a turbo
      Join Date
      Sep 2010
      Location
      Staunton, Va
      Posts
      207
      Thanks
      0
      Thanked 2 Times in 2 Posts
      yeah... I wouldn't run it with no load on the wire connection like that... looks like you just put a couple thousand volts into the vehicle ground.

    4. #4
      Should I keep it?
      Join Date
      Mar 2015
      Location
      Los Angeles
      Posts
      43
      Thanks
      5
      Thanked 6 Times in 3 Posts
      Quote Originally Posted by exodus0784 View Post
      ... looks like you just put a couple thousand volts into the vehicle ground.
      Tesla would be proud of me

      I did struggle for a week to pass the smoke check, after consulting 3 shops, all of them were suggesting to replace something different to get rid of the P0300 code. So I started with the Spark Plugs, didn't work, then I did replaced the spark plugs cables, didn't work, then I got an after market chip coil, didn't remove the P0300 code.

      Then...


      One of the tech helpers at one of these shops suggested to try to replace the new spark plugs, well I did with another brand and the P0300 code is gone finally. Passed Smoke check easy.

      Do not know why is there so much difference between sparkplugs brands.
      Last edited by itratis; 04-02-2015 at 01:28 AM.

    5. #5
      I'll keep it and add a turbo
      Join Date
      Sep 2010
      Location
      Staunton, Va
      Posts
      207
      Thanks
      0
      Thanked 2 Times in 2 Posts
      Quote Originally Posted by itratis View Post
      Tesla would be proud of me

      I did struggle for a week to pass the smoke check, after consulting 3 shops, all of them were suggesting to replace something different to get rid of the P0300 code. So I started with the Spark Plugs, didn't work, then I did replaced the spark plugs cables, didn't work, then I got an after market chip coil, didn't remove the P0300 code.

      Then...


      One of the tech helpers at one of this shops suggested to try to replace the new spark plugs, well I did with another brand and the P0300 code is gone finally. Passed Smoke check easy.

      Do not know why is there so much difference between sparkplugs brands.
      I for one would purchased your patented tesla coil based ignition system.

      On the plugs, you didn't throw platinums in, did you? I thought there was some issue where you had to use copper or iridium or you'd end up with misfires (which would explain the p0300, rather than a cylinder specific code)... I could be making that up, though.

      But yeah, I think the "correct" ... but still sparky way of checking the ignition coil is to mist it with the wires on... personally I would spray it while it wasn't running and then turn it on... call me captain safety, though. The fact that the spark is jumping that far through atmosphere shows you how much voltage there is.

    6. #6
      Should I keep it?
      Join Date
      Mar 2015
      Location
      Los Angeles
      Posts
      43
      Thanks
      5
      Thanked 6 Times in 3 Posts
      I did got what was recommended at AZ, the brand was Autolite and you are correct they were Platinum. The new ones are also platinum but AC Delco.

      The best way to test a high voltage device is to stick a wet finger in it, then according to the heat it generates we can calculate current, voltage and resistance, I mean if we survive

      NO, You are right safety first.
      Last edited by itratis; 04-02-2015 at 03:02 AM.

    7. #7
      What do you mean there's no turbo? PoisonIvy's Avatar
      Join Date
      Mar 2013
      Location
      Canada
      Posts
      393
      Thanks
      10
      Thanked 56 Times in 49 Posts
      Yeah, from reading on here for a couple years, it seems like Aveos are picky on spark plugs. They just don't like Platinum plugs. Either Iridium or Copper are the way to go. I have $2 NGK Coppers in mine. I'll just have to change them more frequently.

    8. #8
      What do you mean there's no turbo?
      Join Date
      Jul 2014
      Location
      Long Island, NY
      Posts
      308
      Thanks
      0
      Thanked 50 Times in 48 Posts
      Did you gap your plugs to the correct spec?
      2004 Aveo beater car
      2005 Aveo LT. 5-speed beater car (DOA)

    9. #9
      Should I keep it?
      Join Date
      Mar 2015
      Location
      Los Angeles
      Posts
      43
      Thanks
      5
      Thanked 6 Times in 3 Posts
      I did to 0.043

    10. #10
      Almost time to do my timing belt xintersecty's Avatar
      Join Date
      Sep 2010
      Location
      West Union, SC
      Posts
      1,687
      Thanks
      86
      Thanked 181 Times in 156 Posts
      If I remember, I think .043 is right. I found this article/post on spark plug gap with regards to magnetos. Using the above Tesla Open Air Coil that might change things. I know our plugs are fired by electronic switches and coils, however it is a fascinating read:


      Reference: why does spark plug type or gap even matter? - SmokStak
      I will address your question in parts:
      1) Gap: on older engines, especially those with mags, gap is critical to prevent coil failure. Most older engines want about .025 to .030 gap, but there are some out there than need .020, no more. (Mayteg 82 and 92 for instance) Use a wider gap and you risk a chance of burning out the secondary windings in the coil. In the 72 twins, setting the gap wider than .025 invites coil failure in the 72-D and DA models - again weak coils. Most small engines, used on mowers and small equipment use a .030 gap, but it is best to use manufacturers recomendations. If you don't have the specs, then, have a look on the internet, and try to find it. If you can't find them, try .020" and see if the engine will run on it. I have seen engines run on as little as .010" gap, but fouling will be problematic. You might get a 1/4" spark out of the engine, but you may not get a spark under compression, if the voltage and current are weak.

      If you have a weak coil, or one that is failing, closing the gap may keep the engine running a little longer. Most older coils are going to have degradation of the high tension insulation. This will cause spark to jump between the windings, causing corrosion and carbonization . This in turn spreads between the winding layers, shorting the coil and causing a drop in power out put. Having a too wide a gap increases the voltage and current needed to jump the gap under compression, inviting the spark to jump at the weakest point. This is what causes coil failure, especially if the insulation is weak to begin with.

      On modern automobiles, gap also helps ignite leaner charges now used. With todays lean burn engines, you might not even get ignition at a .035 gap. GM, with their HEI electronic ignition, used a .060 gap! Put that large a gap on a mower, and you probably will burn out a coil in short order, if you get spark at all!

      2) Heat range: The heat range on a spark plug is determined by the engine manufacturer. It is determined by the compression ratio, combustion pressure , cooling method, combustion chamber design, and other factors. Running too hot a plug will cause the electrodes to burn off, make the insulater crack and fail, create excessive heat in the combustion chamber, and probably may create detonation which may be inaudibal (you won't hear it), but will be destructive to internal engine componants. In aluminum head engines, I have seen several air cooled engines that have actually melted the plug mount threads out, ejecting the hot plug at a good velocity!

      Running a plug that is too cool, and you will get carbon build up and an incomplete burn of fuel in the combustion chamber. This will foul the plug. Fouling will decrease heat and will short out the plug under compression, as well as create a loss of power in the long run.

      Running a plug that is not designned for the engine may also be problematic. Engines have different reaches - the length needed to get the electrodes and the working end of the plug to the point needed for best ignition charactoristics. Putting a short thread plug in a long reach head invites head damage - carbon build up in the exposed threads and or burning of the head material itself. Trying to install the proper plug at a later date will cause galling in the head threads, and possibly a busted or fouled plug. Putting too long a plug in a short reach head may cause valve/piston damage thru direct contact, or may cause plug threads to be exposed within the combustion chamber. The engine might run with too long a plug, but when you try to remove it, carbon, ash and combustion debris left on the threads will tear up the head threads. I have seen several examples where a too long plug actually broke off in the head - jammed bu the combustion debris left on the exposed threads. Installing plugs with the wrong electrode reach will probably cause ignition problems - the engine power produced will be compromised.

      Older small engines, for the most part, are gap critical. You do not want too wide a gap due to the age / condition of the coil used. They are more tolerant of heat range, but it is still important. Larger, multi cylinder engines, like those used in autos, especially those built into the 1960s and later, are heat range critical as well. Too hot a plug will cause damage as noted above. Racing engines have their own set of damands, where gap, heat range, engine heat build up and application, and fuel used are all important.

      Heat range is determined in the plugs, by several factors: The thickness and extension of the insulator on the center electrode, the length of the electrodes into the combustion chamber, and the length of the plug itself. Fuel quality to be used in the engine is also taken into consideration. Today's fuel has alcohol in it for the most part. Manufacturers in their infinite wisdom, have decided to cut costs by eliminating the glaze on the insulator. The problem is if these new plugs are used in older engines, with a rich fuel environment, they tend to foul easily. They perform poorly in the old engines. Also, the new fuel tends to short under compression. That is why you cannot prime an auto that runs out of gas. If you put liquid gas into the air inlet, you probably will short the plugs. Even new plugs will short out under compression, if they are wet with fuel. In the old engines, this type of fouling is becoming problematic, as wetting the plugs with the choke on, is shorting them. They will fire out of the engine, but not under compression. In today's throwaway society, nobody bothers to check why a plug isn't working, they just buy another one. In the 'old days', mechaincs used to put the plugs into a tester and apply compression pressure to see if a plug will work. No more, just toss it and buy a new one.

      Hope this helps explain things a bit. This is s simplified answer, if you need more specific answers, please ask. There are no such thing as stupid questiions - everyone has something to learn, if they don't know the answer.
      Andrew





      Please do not power off, firmware update pending.....

    Similar Threads

    1. Coil pack?
      By cheap is better in forum How-To
      Replies: 2
      Last Post: 07-08-2014, 12:42 AM
    2. coil pack
      By nightmare in forum Engine & Drivetrain
      Replies: 4
      Last Post: 03-18-2014, 01:05 AM
    3. where can I buy a spring coil?
      By mcutler in forum Products
      Replies: 2
      Last Post: 01-10-2013, 05:05 PM
    4. cooling coil
      By hungrywolf76 in forum Engine & Drivetrain
      Replies: 1
      Last Post: 08-28-2012, 06:16 PM
    5. coil pack
      By pacmanaveo in forum Engine & Drivetrain
      Replies: 5
      Last Post: 08-21-2008, 11:06 PM

    Posting Permissions

    • You may not post new threads
    • You may not post replies
    • You may not post attachments
    • You may not edit your posts
    •