Originally Posted by
petrified.rabbit
IF the car is fixed right, then you essentially will have a new top end at this point, which means the engine will be better than buying a new car within the same price range. But you have o make sure your mechanic is going to stand behind their work. Than all the proper timing components were replaced.
now the real issue is what are they going to try to charge you for. IF he screwed up the timing like you wrote, and that is what cause the valve damage, this work should be cost free to rectify the problem. But you would need the second shop to have verified the timing was off, and take it back to the first mechanic (they have insurance for this, and also contact the BBB). The big issue is time. How long between the first mechanic and the problems, or did he not fix it correctly and you had it towed from there?
honestly as well, this lot sounds like a bunch of crooks, or at most, they have good intentions but are selling crappy cars for huge mark up. I would probably look for a new mechanic/dealer after this issue is resolved. Ask around, use angieslist, etc. Find a good mechanic, use him for little things first to test his service/reliability/honesty.