•  
    Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
    Results 1 to 10 of 25

    Thread: attention 5 spd owners...... do this test....

    1. #1
      What's wrong with my car?
      Join Date
      Sep 2008
      Posts
      8
      Garage empty: add car
      Thanks
      0
      Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

      attention 5 spd owners...... do this test....

      turn your radio off...... close all your windows..... after 80km/h or 50mph put your car in 5th gear....... slowly accelerate and listen carefully for humming or vibration at around 95 km/h or 55 mph.... my car was 3 days old when I finally took it on the highway......
      I am experiencing an intermittent vibration/humming noise only in 5th.... not in 4th or any other gear.... my car now has 4500 kms on it..... and the dealer has ordered me a new tranny...... and I had to keep going back..... I wouldn't settle for the answer " it's a bit noisy.... what do you want from an entry level vehicle....... you should've bought an SX4"
      I don't think so........ I listen very carefully to my car........ there could be a few ppl out there that listen to the tunes or love their exhaust a little loud.... DO THIS TEST !!!

      if your tranny goes after the warranty...... you're easily looking at about $3500

      Steve btw... for ontario ppl soozookey of brampton sux !!!!!



    2. #2
      Still love my daily driver khan4rtist's Avatar
      Join Date
      Dec 2006
      Location
      Fontana, California
      Posts
      883
      Thanks
      0
      Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

      Re: attention 5 spd owners...... do this test....

      i dont get any humming....then again i have no sound insulation and i have an exhaust, but the dealer is right...what do you expect for a cheap $10k korean car?? i wouldnt be worried about it, my car makes a couple of noises but nothing to get worried about, its just the quality of the parts used to build an economy car.

    3. #3
      Lifetime owner
      Join Date
      Sep 2008
      Location
      Pittsburgh
      Posts
      8,013
      Garage empty: add car
      Thanks
      2
      Thanked 171 Times in 142 Posts

      Re: attention 5 spd owners...... do this test....

      my car mermers in fifth above 80 mph.. sounds kind of like exhaust putting, but more like the clutch slipping or not enough fluid in the tranny like gears spinning... it starts low gets lowered and then stops (without knowing a better way to say it) at about 10 beats per second.


    4. #4
      I'll keep it and add a turbo
      Join Date
      Oct 2007
      Location
      Bradenton, FL
      Posts
      116
      Thanks
      0
      Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post

      Re: attention 5 spd owners...... do this test....

      Mine has been doing this since I got it. It only happens between 50-60mph, constant speed. Only one other person has noticed it while riding with me in my car, its very quiet. My car turned 15k miles today, and the sound is the same, maybe quieter compared with when it was new. It really isn't that loud, and I don't think it is indicative of a problem. I'd characterize the sound as this: 1 second of low soft drone followed by 1 second of no noise. It keeps repeating at this interval. Considering I've got the 5yr/100k mile warranty, if it turns out to be a problem, I'll get it fixed under warranty. I've still got 4 years left of warranty, and by the time its up, I should have plenty of money for a new car.

      Its no big deal IMO. The fact that there is a noise doesn't necessarily mean there is a problem. If your dealer tells you that there is a legitimate mechanical problem, let me know. I'll also let you know if I ever have a problem with it.

      I've got a 2007 5spd LS Sedan btw.

    5. #5
      What's wrong with my car?
      Join Date
      Sep 2008
      Posts
      8
      Garage empty: add car
      Thanks
      0
      Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

      Re: attention 5 spd owners...... do this test....

      I'd like to start by saying.... that I've owned about 19 cars in my life~~ all manual transmission.... never had 1 that made humming noises in 5th gear.. I do 98% of my driving at 100 km/h or faster......
      after taxes and applicable fees my swift was $14000.00....not $10000.00
      if I hear a strange intermittent vibration in 5th gear on a brand new car whether I paid 14 or 50 grand for it..... I want it fixed..... I don't live with mummy & daddy..... I work hard for my money.... and having a mortgage and family to support.... this car isn't my "toy" it has to get me to work and back for a few years..... so I am worried about it...... and if it wasn't serious, I don't think my new tranny would be on it's way here from Korea !!!!!
      people settling for less than average service or products are the reason that imports are sailing past domestics in all categories~~
      just my 2 cents....... Steve

    6. #6
      Almost time to do my timing belt NYChevoo's Avatar
      Join Date
      Apr 2008
      Location
      Brewster,NY
      Posts
      1,811
      Thanks
      1
      Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

      Re: attention 5 spd owners...... do this test....

      man am i glad i have an automatic!!
      Missing our beloved 1st gen Aveos everyday!
      Silence is golden. Duct tape is silver!!
      04 Aveo (mine gone but never forgotten)
      07 Aveo 5 (wifes car gone but never forgotten)
      02 Suburban (Eats gas stations as snacks)
      12 Cruze Eco 6MT
      (46mpg daily? Holy crap!)
      12 Sonic 2LT (Wifeys new wheels)

      Chevoo-1/2 Chevy, 1/2 Daewoo. I mean like WTF?

    7. #7
      Lifetime owner
      Join Date
      Sep 2008
      Location
      Pittsburgh
      Posts
      8,013
      Garage empty: add car
      Thanks
      2
      Thanked 171 Times in 142 Posts

      Re: attention 5 spd owners...... do this test....

      Quote Originally Posted by crawdaddy
      I'd like to start by saying.... that I've owned about 19 cars in my life~~ all manual transmission.... never had 1 that made humming noises in 5th gear.. I do 98% of my driving at 100 km/h or faster......
      after taxes and applicable fees my swift was $14000.00....not $10000.00
      if I hear a strange intermittent vibration in 5th gear on a brand new car whether I paid 14 or 50 grand for it..... I want it fixed..... I don't live with mummy & daddy..... I work hard for my money.... and having a mortgage and family to support.... this car isn't my "toy" it has to get me to work and back for a few years..... so I am worried about it...... and if it wasn't serious, I don't think my new tranny would be on it's way here from Korea !!!!!
      people settling for less than average service or products are the reason that imports are sailing past domestics in all categories~~
      just my 2 cents....... Steve

      I am in the same boat you are, married, two kids, and my parents like 2000 miles away. you didn't say how old you are. but i am 29 and have owned 56 cars (only counting the legal registered inspect daily drivers) probably 30 or so manuals. But the noise was there on the test drive. I am figuring since it is an overdrive gear, it is either outside the case so you can hear it (MANY VW 5 SPEEDS ARE LIKE THIS) or the gear is cut straighter than the rest of the set, if you have never heard straight cut gears this is still quieter. im not going to know if either answer is correct unless i tear the tranny apart. but i know the mermer my car has is a lot quieter than the some of the hyundai, toyota and focus transmissions i have had as rental cars. and i know that it is highly likely that the noise is present in more cars but you don't hear it because of insulation or other features this car doesn't have. I have heard whining transmissions in brand $60k Escalades. so you are correct: What you pay for a car does not determine quality, (my $40k audi blew the engine and turbo at 38k miles), so regardless if you own an aveo or a ferrari (or both) if you are concerned they should fix it. i just feel my car only has 1800 miles, im not going to take it back for a noisy gear, since it is under warranty, ill just wait for the tranny to go but when i take it for its 3k miles oil change, i will test drive other aveos to see if it is the same and mention it to my mechanic. But I think the big difference in your description and everyone else's is we have said "noise" and you say a "vibration". i have absolutely no vibration associated with it. any vibration i had went away with my lowering springs. so if you still have a vibration after they fix the tranny, i suggest you look into suspension. mine had a slight vibration anywhere from 50-80 mph, but only while hold a constant speed, it doesn't occur if you accelerate or decelerate through it. my lowering springs fixed it.


    8. #8
      I'll keep it and add a turbo
      Join Date
      Oct 2007
      Location
      Bradenton, FL
      Posts
      116
      Thanks
      0
      Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post

      Re: attention 5 spd owners...... do this test....

      OK so scratch what I wrote before... the noise/vibration is definitely gone. I was going off my memory of a year ago when I first noticed it, and thought the humming it was still there. Cars don't magically fix themselves, right?

      Well, after driving around 50 miles today, most of it in the 50-60mph range, I could not duplicate the noise that I remembered from last year. Maybe thats why I didn't think it was a big deal. The humming was pretty quiet to begin with, so I thought I had learned to tune it out. But really, I couldn't hear it at all anymore. So scratch me off the list of those who still have a problem with the 5 spd. Mine probably just needed to be broken in.

    9. #9
      What do you mean there's no turbo?
      Join Date
      Feb 2008
      Posts
      312
      Garage empty: add car
      Thanks
      0
      Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post

      Re: attention 5 spd owners...... do this test....

      Quote Originally Posted by petrified.rabbit

      I am in the same boat you are, married, two kids, and my parents like 2000 miles away. you didn't say how old you are. but i am 29 and have owned 56 cars (only counting the legal registered inspect daily drivers) probably 30 or so manuals. But the noise was there on the test drive. I am figuring since it is an overdrive gear, it is either outside the case so you can hear it (MANY VW 5 SPEEDS ARE LIKE THIS) or the gear is cut straighter than the rest of the set, if you have never heard straight cut gears this is still quieter. im not going to know if either answer is correct unless i tear the tranny apart.
      I don't think car manufacturers use straight cut gears except for reverse in a manual tranny..

    10. #10
      What do you mean there's no turbo?
      Join Date
      Apr 2008
      Location
      Bonnyville, Alberta
      Posts
      308
      Garage empty: add car
      Thanks
      0
      Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

      Re: attention 5 spd owners...... do this test....

      +1





    Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast

    Posting Permissions

    • You may not post new threads
    • You may not post replies
    • You may not post attachments
    • You may not edit your posts
    •