Interesting post there Bree (and thanks for supplying all of that detail). Sounds like this is a better mouse trap. Any comments from Rabbit, or others who have done this job previously using the "book" method?
Interesting post there Bree (and thanks for supplying all of that detail). Sounds like this is a better mouse trap. Any comments from Rabbit, or others who have done this job previously using the "book" method?
bree's method would work, i would guess it just depends on the tools and facilities you have available.
i would still drop the k-frame, im not talking about total removal. instead of the kframe, he disconnected the alignment points on the struts, which means your alignment will still be off (will be off removing the k frame.) the difference between his method and removing the kframe is the dropping of the transmission, his would come out and slide foward to come out of the car.
honestly. i've done many vws his way. figure out which way will work best for you.
I have not read the "book" i have a feeling the like Bree, experience's common sense outweighs what the book can tell you.
Thanks Rabbit - tools/facilities is the key item for an amature tree DIY guy like me. The more "special" (i.e. one-time) tools need to be purchased, the less worthwhile it becomes to DIY. I have a few breaker bars and a basic tool set, supplemented by the very helpful Autozone loan-a-tool program. So if this job ever becomes necessary for my '05, I would be willing to consider trying it by following the steps that Bree used. No problem putting in extra hours to get the job done, but I'd be really ticked off if it ended up costing more on a DIY than it would have in a shop. It would be interesting what the airline mechanic OP would have say about Bree's approach, but he's probably not going to be following up on this.
even with brees method, for safety you should support the engine. I have something like this:
Astro Pneumatic 5820 Transverse Engine Support Bar 31" Minimum To 64" Maximum | Engine Handling Equipment | Stands | Equipment and Supplies | Automotive | Toolfetch
however, you could use a 2x4 and a chain.. it not only keep the engine from "falling out" as a potential injury hazard. since it is only held up by a jack, it keeps the wires hoses etc form becoming stretched should the engine start to hang. keep in mind, his method also only has the engine being help up by one mount.