Originally Posted by
dbooyah93
…
Here's the deal. All but one spark plug was soaked in oil and we already replaced the valve cover gasket.
I'm worried it's piston rings.
I'm assuming you're saying that oil was on the plugs above the threads. If so, there are a few ways to mess up the VC gasket install (primarily torqueing incorrectly), and that would be my first suspect. When replacing the VC gasket you should use an (inch) torque wrench and tighten the bolts incrementally and in proper sequence. And also use (a very small amount of) RTV only at the transition points.
Did you also replace the plug wires? If not, a plug wire is highly likely to be the cause of the misfire.