I take part in multiple auto forums, and based on my own experience, don't agree with that statement in any way. I've seen a number of folks reply to advice that I've given, confirming it worked for them. And on the other side, I've received tons of help from reading what other have done, and have tried to confirm positive results to them as well. And I personally know of many other guys who do the same as I do.
Now if you're bothered by the fact that so many people post a problem and never reply with their result, well that's just the way it is, and it's not going to change. I never expect a reply when I post - it does happen some of the time, but more often there is no reply or result posted. But regardless of that, the overall benefit from these forums is HUGE. And for certain there are sometimes disagreements about which way is best, but there's nothing wrong with that either, and it ususally results in lots of information.
A perfect example is this thread. I've never had to replace the alt on one of our Aveos, but have followed the various threads because eventually it probably will happen. So when I read the post by smrh20, I wanted to take a look at this myself. But it's been so cold here in MA that this evening was the first time I could crawl under and check out what he wrote.
And so I'll say thanks to smrh20 for your info. It looks good to me, and I'll definitely try that route, if and when I have to do this job